Daniel Press of the Competitive Enterprise Institute calls the US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s name “the ultimate misnomer.” He’s right. The “Protection” part only makes sense in the manner of mob racket slang: “Nice loan operation you got there. Be a shame if anything happened to it.”
The CFPB’s latest attack on the poor is a rule putting new restrictions on much-maligned “payday lenders.” Or, to come at it from the other direction, new restrictions on the ability of people to borrow money.
If you’ve ever lived on the low end of the income scale (and yes, I have), chances are you’ve run into unexpected, even emergency, situations where you need cash and need it now. If you’re on that low end of the income scale, you probably don’t have a credit card, or substantial savings, or the ability to take out a bank loan (you may not even have a bank account).
Back when I was in that kind of situation (I distinctly recall once needing to pay for a prescription for a sick toddler, with no health insurance to take the edge off the price) the first-line solution was the local pawn shop. Take something that’s worth a little money — your television, for example — get the money you need, then pay it back ASAP or over time, with interest, and get your TV back. Or, if you can’t manage the payments, it eventually gets sold.
Pawn shops still exist, but I suspect payday lending has cut into their business quite a bit. If you’re employed and get a regular paycheck, a payday lender will advance you some money, which you pay back with interest.
Yes, it’s high interest by comparison to, say, a home mortgage. Yes, some people get dragged down into recurring cycles of borrow and pay. Being poor sucks. Believe me, I know.
But CFPB’s “solution” is far worse than the alleged problem. Their rules just make it harder for you to get a loan, as if some Washington bureaucrat knows your finances and your needs better than you do. You and that bureaucrat have a lot in common: Both of you want to run your life.
People who need money will do what they have to do to get that money. The bottom line of these rules is that CFPB would rather you went to a loan shark, or robbed a liquor store, or sold your children into sex slavery, than paid interest rates they consider too high.
The only worthwhile rule pertaining to payday lending (or any other kind of lending) is to require that lenders be clear and truthful about their terms. Beyond that, the decision to borrow is rightfully yours, not CFPB’s.
Thomas L. Knapp (Twitter: @thomaslknapp) is director and senior news analyst at the William Lloyd Garrison Center for Libertarian Advocacy Journalism (thegarrisoncenter.org). He lives and works in north central Florida.
- “CFPB makes war on the poor in the name of ‘protecting’ them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, Winchester, Tennessee Herald Chronicle, 05/07/18
- “CFPB makes war on the poor,” Hendricks County, Indiana Flyer, 05/07/18
- “CFPB makes war on the poor in the name of ‘protecting’ them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, Kinston, North Carolina Free Press, 05/07/18
- “CFPB makes war on the poor in the name of ‘protecting’ them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, New Bern, North Carolina Sun Journal, 05/07/18
- CFPB makes war on the poor in the name of ‘protecting’ them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, Jacksonville, North Carolina Daily News, 05/07/18
- CFPB makes war on the poor in the name of ‘protecting’ them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, Kinston, North Carolina Free Press, 05/07/18
- “CFPB Makes War on the Poor in the name of ‘Protecting’ Them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, OpEdNews, 05/08/18
- “CFPB makes war on poor in the name of protecting them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, Florence, South Carolina News Journal [web and print editions], 05/08/18
- “CFPB Makes War on the Poor in the name of ‘Protecting’ Them,” by Thomas L. Knapp, Uintah Basin, Utah Standard/Vernal Express, 05/08/18
- “War on the poor in the name of protection,” by Thomas L. Knapp, Richmond County, North Carolina Daily Journal, 05/09/18