Rumors of the GOP’s Demise are Exaggerated, but There’s Still Good News

Libertarian Party Logo
Libertarian Party Logo (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

As a callow youth, I cast my first vote in a presidential election for Michael Dukakis, the Democratic Party’s 1988 nominee. Since then, I’ve never again voted for a Democrat or Republican for president. If George HW Bush had bothered to read his own lips in 1992, he’d have had my vote and I might never have ended up as a Libertarian Party member, activist and candidate. Thanks, George.

Nearly a quarter of a century later,  160 years into its life as a national political organization and 156 years after it became the most recent new party to put up a winning presidential candidate,  the Grand Old Party seems to be coming apart at the seams thanks to Donald Trump.

That’s probably an illusion. Fifty years from now this year will most likely have been, in retrospect, just another inflection point. It would be far from the first. Eisenhower’s defeat of Taft in 1952 made the Republicans the party of Cold War instead of non-interventionism. The period connecting Goldwater and Reagan spanned several major changes including but not limited to a rhetorical co-option of libertarianism at those end points and Nixon’s actual co-option of the formerly Democratic “Solid South.”

The Republican Party may be imploding, or it may just be shifting gears. Either way, I’m relieved. Not because I necessarily think New GOP will be any better than Classic GOP. But at least it will be less vexing on one front:

For my entire adult life, Republicans have campaigned as libertarians and governed as Democrats. I doubt we’ll see any major change on the latter point. But it will make my year (heck, my decade) if this election cycle means America stops running off to bed with a beer-goggles-induced Thomas Jefferson on the first Tuesday night every fourth November and waking up next to Hubert Humphrey the following morning.

If you’re a conservative or a progressive, okay. Just be that, take pride in it, and openly act on it instead of trying to convince yourself (and everyone around you) that you’re something else.

If you love freedom, though, this election cycle should be the point where you stop screwing around and get serious. You’ve GOT a political party, the Libertarian Party. We’ve been around for nearly half a century. We’re America’s third largest political party. We’ve elected hundreds of local officials and even some state legislators.  Let’s hit the next level together. And welcome home.

Thomas L. Knapp (Twitter: @thomaslknapp) is director and senior news analyst at the William Lloyd Garrison Center for Libertarian Advocacy Journalism ( He lives and works in north central Florida.


Also published on Medium.

  • Nicolas Leobold

    Be careful about voting because doing so can be construed as a tacit endorsement of the state and system.

    • I’ve read quite a few arguments on that subject, and really, the farthest I can go might be to classify voting as a waste of time. The state/system exist and have made it pretty clear they plan to continue exist whether or not they get an endorsement, so voting or not voting doesn’t really play to that concern much.

      I’m not a big Rothbardian, but I do consider his position on voting worthwhile, as summarized in the argument that if slaves are offered their choice of overseers, they’re not immoral for exercising that choice in favor of the one who seems likely to beat them less.

      As far as this site/column are concerned, don’t be surprised if you see a “why bother to vote at all?” column or three here over time. Sometimes I try to give the reader’s shoulders a gentle tap, sometimes a slap across the face. This one is in gentle tap territory. We’re in an election cycle and I’m trying to direct voters’ attention away from the existing regime and toward alternatives. Those alternatives won’t ALWAYS be voting/political but at this particular time voting/political stuff seemed like a good approach to take.

  • Delaney Coffer

    The notion that the republican party is going through some massive change is baseless. Trump is Trump. He isn’t the republican party. The people who make a living being “real conservatives” are shitting their pants right now, but that is mostly because they’re realizing their orthodoxy has let them down. Trump will do what he says because he has no reason to do anything else. He’s quite liberated in that way. What is more worthy of note is how openly Marxist the democrat party has become. While college kids can get internet press like mad, their portion of the electorate amounts to right around dick shit. This is starting to look like a foregone conclusion.

  • Pingback: Random Shots for Monday, 9 May 2016 | Nemo Me Impune Lacessit()

  • Disestablishmentarian

    I live in California and I re-registered as Libertarian to keep that party on the ballot. And I’ve often voted for the party name to show my dissatisfaction with the GOP. In California it has been for some time a free vote. But not this year. Gary Johnson’s open-borderism is a deal breaker.